Counter Catcher only works while the player is behind on Prizes, letting them pull a Benched Pokémon into the opponent's Active Spot. The original Crimson Invasion wording described this as switching the Benched Pokémon with the opponent's Active Pokémon, while the Paradox Rift wording simplified the phrasing to switching in the Benched Pokémon to the Active Spot.
Counter Catcher debuted in the Sun and Moon era's Crimson Invasion with both a Secret Rare and a standard Uncommon printing, then returned in the Scarlet and Violet era's Paradox Rift with an Uncommon and a Hyper Rare printing. Toyste Beach illustrated every printing. Our catalog lists 4 printings across 2 sets.
Both Crimson Invasion printings share the original wording, and both Paradox Rift printings share the updated wording, so the two sets mark the card's two distinct effect texts rather than gradual changes within a set.
The Crimson Invasion Secret Rare printing is a rarer version of the card's first release
The Crimson Invasion Uncommon printing is Counter Catcher's standard first release
The Paradox Rift Hyper Rare printing carries the updated Active Spot wording
Only when the player has more Prize cards remaining than their opponent.
The wording was simplified from switching the Benched Pokémon with the Active Pokémon to switching it into the Active Spot.
From Crimson Invasion (2017) · 1 printing
You can play this card only if you have more Prize cards remaining than your opponent. Switch 1 of your opponent’s Benched Pokémon with their Active Pokémon.
From Paradox Rift (2023) · 2 printings
You can use this card only if you have more Prize cards remaining than your opponent. Switch in 1 of your opponent's Benched Pokémon to the Active Spot.

Counter Catcher
Item
First printed in Crimson Invasion (2017)
You can use this card only if you have more Prize cards remaining than your opponent. Switch in 1 of your opponent's Benched Pokémon to the Active Spot.
Counter CatcherParadox Rift · 264$1.76-4.3%58Quant score58 / 100
Counter CatcherCrimson Invasion · 120$5.37-1.5%24Quant score24 / 100
Counter CatcherParadox Rift · 160 · Normal$0.26-7.1%67Quant score67 / 100
Counter CatcherCrimson Invasion · 91 · Normal$0.50+2.0%59Quant score59 / 100