Strictly Mint Card Co.
Store · Smithtown, NY · Sports Cards111 Plymouth Blvd, Smithtown, NY
Hours
| Sun | Closed | |
|---|---|---|
| Mon | 11 am – 7 pm | |
| Tue | 11 am – 7 pm | |
| Wed | 11 am – 7 pm | Today |
| Thu | 11 am – 7 pm | |
| Fri | 11 am – 7 pm | |
| Sat | Closed |
Map
111 Plymouth Blvd, Smithtown, NY
About
Strictly Mint Card Co. is a family-owned sports card business at 111 Plymouth Blvd in Smithtown, New York. It has been in business since 1986 and has filled mail orders for more than 30 years, so it suits collectors who want a deep catalog of baseball, football, basketball and hockey cards from a seller whose two owners handle every order and answer the phone themselves. It is a mail-order operation first, with weekday hours for phone contact.
The catalog covers baseball, football, NBA and NHL cards. Baseball is the deepest category. It runs from boxes and cases (2015 through 2026) to factory and complete sets organized year by year, from 1913 through 2025, with team sets for every MLB club. Star and rookie cards are sorted by player, from legends such as Babe Ruth, Mickey Mantle, Jackie Robinson and Nolan Ryan to current names like Shohei Ohtani, Aaron Judge, Mookie Betts and Elly De La Cruz. A section of game-used jerseys and autographs sits alongside a rookie card index running A to Z.
Basketball is organized the same way: boxes, complete sets grouped by era from older sets through 2024-25, team sets for all 30 clubs, and player sections that include Larry Bird, Kobe Bryant, Stephen Curry, Luka Doncic, Anthony Edwards and LaMelo Ball.
The business is built around orders placed by phone, email or at checkout, and the two owners, a married couple, handle every part of each order themselves. Most orders placed by 1 PM Eastern ship the same business day. International orders ship to more than 50 countries, with the cost calculated at checkout.
| Order total | U.S. shipping |
|---|---|
| $0.00 to $19.99 | $4.95 |
| $20.00 to $99.99 | $7.95 |
| $100.00 to $199.99 | $9.95 |
| $200.00 and up | Free |
Customs fees such as duties and VAT may apply to international orders, depending on the order's value and the destination country's rules.
Orders of $100 or more can go on a layaway plan, paid in four equal monthly installments by check, money order, PayPal or automatic credit card billing. The price is held regardless of market movement, and the cards ship as soon as the final payment arrives. Payments can be made faster than the schedule, but the plan runs at most four months. Each customer may have one active layaway at a time. Once started, a layaway cannot be canceled or changed, because the cards are pulled from inventory right away, and deposits are non-refundable and forfeited if the layaway is not resolved within five months of the start date.
Returns are accepted within 10 days of receipt, and only if the items come back in the condition in which they shipped. Factory sealed sets must still be sealed and unopened, boxes of packs must still be sealed, and hand-collated sets must still be complete.
| Day | Hours |
|---|---|
| Monday to Friday | 11 AM to 7 PM |
| Saturday | Closed |
| Sunday | Closed |
Hours are Eastern time, and the phone line is staffed during them.
The business dates to 1986. It has remained a two-person family operation through decades of mail-order work, which is why the same two people take every call and send every email.
Several other stores sit within a few miles: Kyle's Comics in Smithtown at about 1 mile, Island Hobby Nut in Commack at about 1.5 miles, Game On in Smithtown at about 1.8 miles, LI Toy & Game in Kings Park at about 2.1 miles, and Royal East Collectibles in Smithtown at about 2.2 miles. For a larger floor, the Long Island TCG Show (about 11.7 miles away) and the Plainview Local Card Show (about 12.6 miles) both have their next dates on November 8, 2026.
Nearby stores
Reviews
No reviews yet
Nearby shows