Overtime Cards

Overtime Cards is a card shop at 1153 E Expressway Lane in Spanish Fork, Utah, one of two locations the business runs, the other in Sandy. It carries Pokémon and sports cards, buys and trades collections, and works as an approved PSA dealer for grading and autograph authentication. The business has been in Utah since 1996, and it suits collectors who want a shop that mixes sealed product and singles with trade nights, kids programs and athlete signings.

What's on the shelves

The shop sells sealed wax and singles in sports cards and Pokémon, along with other trading card games. A Rip Desk lets customers open the newest releases in the shop, and singles can be browsed box by box. The stated aim is a shop that serves collectors at every level and keeps the atmosphere conversational. eGift cards can be used for in-store purchases.

Buying and trading

The store buys and trades collections every day, paying in cash or in-store credit. It takes baseball, football, basketball and other sports cards, plus Pokémon and other TCG cards, both modern and vintage. The buying rules are specific:

• Cards in excellent condition are preferred, and graded cards are a priority.
• Cards need to be worth more than $5.
• Sports cards from the junk wax era, 1987 to the mid-1990s, are generally passed on. Exceptions include Michael Jordan, Kobe Bryant and Hall of Fame rookie cards from the major sports.
• Only cards are bought. Sealed wax, memorabilia and other collectibles are not.

Sellers join a waitlist, and a staff member evaluates the collection. Saturday is the busiest day, so longer waits are likely, and waitlist sign-up closes one hour before the shop does. Purchases depend on current inventory needs, and the store can decline any collection.

Grading and autographs

As an approved PSA dealer, the shop handles submissions for customers. Cards are brought in, the grading level and an optional cleaning service are chosen, and grading and shipping fees are paid at the shop. Submission status can then be tracked online. The shop also helps with sending signed memorabilia to PSA for autograph authentication and grading, with pricing that depends on the signer, the number of signers and the item.

Events

Events are announced by date rather than on a fixed weekly schedule. Recent and upcoming ones include:

• Trade nights, where collectors bring sports and TCG cards to trade, such as the one on Saturday, October 17, 2026, from 5 to 7 PM.
• Sweet Trades, a morning trade session with donuts, drinks and giveaways, held August 22.
• FIFA World Cup sticker swaps in July, for trading extra soccer stickers and albums.
• Athlete signing events, including Kailer Yamamoto on October 23, 2026, and MacKenzie Weegar of the Utah Mammoth on November 20, 2026. Signings require a purchased ticket, and the Sandy shop hosts the Weegar event.
• Free pack giveaways for kids in late October, for honor roll students and for trick-or-treaters in costume.

Kids camps cover the basics of card collecting for children 8 and older. The shop also takes part in regional card shows, with a booth planned at a Sports Card & TCG Show at the Mountain America Expo Center on November 13 and 14, 2026.

Customers with eligible 2026 Topps UCC Chrome Harry Kane cards can exchange them for in-store credit through a buyback program that runs through January 31, 2027.

Getting there

The Spanish Fork shop is at 1153 E Expressway Lane, Spanish Fork, UT 84660.

The local scene

Spanish Fork has several other game and card stores close by. Game Grid Spanish Fork is about 0.1 miles away, Game Den-Spanish Fork and Game Crazy are about a mile off, and Collector's Haven is roughly 1.5 miles away. Mayday Games in Springville is about 2.6 miles from the shop.