The Graded Gamer
Store · Huntington Beach, CA · Pokémon, Sports Cards7561 Center Ave, Huntington Beach, CA
Map
7561 Center Ave, Huntington Beach, CA
About
The Graded Gamer is a PSA-graded trading card seller based in Huntington Beach, California, with a Center Avenue address. Its shelves lean toward non-sports cards: Marvel, DC and Star Wars sets, plus hockey and other sports cards, with every graded card sent through Professional Sports Authenticator. It suits collectors who care more about a grade on the slab than a table of loose singles, and who are comfortable shopping for it online.
The inventory is graded cards. Marvel is the deepest category, with a long run of vintage and modern Spider-Man, X-Men and Marvel Masterpieces material, and DC cards, Star Wars and other non-sports sets sit alongside it. Hockey cards are part of the mix too. New graded cards arrive from PSA weekly.
Pokémon is carried, but that inventory is sold only online and is not stocked in the store itself.
The store was founded on the idea that mint does not mean the same thing to every collector, and that a third-party grade settles the question. The owners grade exclusively with PSA, and the cards out for grading are tracked in a running list of submissions. As of August 16, 2026, that list was dominated by Marvel cards, including Marvel Metal and Spider-Man Premium pieces and a large group of 2007 Marvel Masterpieces foils, with DC cards beginning further down. Collectors who want to know what is about to come back from PSA can see the pipeline before it lands.
Returns are accepted for any reason within 15 days of the date of sale, as long as the cards come back in the same condition they were sent out in. For a seller of graded cards, that is a generous window.
The Graded Gamer was founded in 2004, after more than ten years of collecting non-sports cards. The founder handled, bought and traded thousands of cards in that time, and the frustration of inconsistent condition standards led to grading. The store also produces video coverage of sets, PSA returns and card shows, and it travels to shows. A Toronto Sports Card Expo, November 5 to 8, is on its calendar.
The address is 7561 Center Ave in Huntington Beach. Walk-in opening hours are not set, so anyone planning a trip in person should confirm the store is open before driving over. The mailing address is a PO Box in Westminster, California.
Several other card and game shops sit a short drive away in Santa Ana: SICC POPS & Collectibles is about 1 mile off, HobbyguysCo about 1.7 miles, Elr Games about 2.1 miles, Thunder’n Games about 2.2 miles and Card Game Coliseum about 2.3 miles. The Regional SoCal Cards & Collectibles Show is about 3.8 miles away and next starts on November 14, 2026. Wolfpack Collectibles TCG Show, about 10.7 miles out, runs on November 3, 10 and 17, and a Yu-Gi-Oh! Regional Qualifier in Los Angeles follows on December 5, about 30.4 miles away.
Nearby stores
Reviews
No reviews yet