BP Sports Cards and Memorabilia

BP Sports Cards and Memorabilia is a card shop at 133 N Main St Unit 4 in Florida, New York, built mainly around sports cards and sealed sports product, with a full trading card game selection alongside. It suits collectors who want baseball, basketball and football boxes, players picking up Pokémon or Magic singles and supplies, and anyone who wants a card shop with a few unusual late-night hours.

What's on the shelves

Sports cards are the core of the stock. The store sorts them by sport: baseball, basketball, football, hockey, soccer, WWE and racing, with other sports and non-sport cards on top. Baseball is divided by year, 2026, 2025, 2024 and 2023 and earlier, and basketball runs from the 2025-26 season back through 2024-25 and 2023-24.

Sealed product is a large part of the sports side. The sports collection runs to 152 items, with hobby boxes, blaster boxes and mega boxes from Topps, Bowman and Panini. A 2026 Topps Allen & Ginter Baseball Hobby Box is $200, and a 2026 Topps Update Series Baseball Hobby Box is $150. Blaster boxes sit lower: a 2026 Topps Allen & Ginter Baseball Blaster Box is $40 and a 2026 Topps Football Blaster Box is $35. A 2026 Topps Football Mega Box is $65.

Specialty items turn up too, including a 2026 Panini FIFA World Cup Soccer 25-Pack Sticker Box and a 2026 Topps Holiday Baseball Advent Calendar Box. The top of the price range reaches $12,999.

On the gaming side the store carries Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh!, Disney Lorcana, Riftbound and Star Wars Unlimited. Supplies include Ultra Pro 50-count standard deck protector sleeves in colors such as blue, lime green, red, orange and pink, with matte versions of some, plus unfoldable card stands at $9.99. The store also sells Warhammer, Funko Pops and Dungeons & Dragons products as collectables.

Hours and getting there

The store keeps an uneven schedule, closed Monday, Tuesday and Thursday.

The Friday window carries on until 6 AM, a rare overnight stretch for a card store.

Shipping and returns

Orders are processed within 1 business day, excluding holidays, and orders placed after noon or on weekends and holidays may start processing the next business day. Shipping goes to addresses in the United States only. Returns can be requested within 30 days after delivery, the customer arranges and pays for return shipping, and the store has to approve a return before anything is sent back.

The local scene

Several other card and game stores sit within a short drive. Darkstone Comics in Chester is 4.1 miles away, and Main Street Comics, ZCGames and Rojas Collectibles in Middletown are between 7.1 and 7.9 miles out, with Creative Games International in Chester at 7.6 miles. For a larger floor, the Tri Cities Card Show, about 26 miles away, next starts on November 4, 2026. The North Jersey Card Show and its late-night edition are about 30 miles away, with dates on November 6 and 7, and a further North Jersey Card Show on November 20.